Brazil turns facial recognition on rioters despite racism fears

A supporter of Brazil's former President Jair Bolsonaro is detained during a demonstration against President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva, outside Planalto Palace in Brasilia, Brazil, January 8, 2023. REUTERS/Ueslei Marcelino

A supporter of Brazil's former President Jair Bolsonaro is detained during a demonstration against President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva, outside Planalto Palace in Brasilia, Brazil, January 8, 2023. REUTERS/Ueslei Marcelino

What’s the context?

Brazil police say they will use facial recognition to identify rioters, despite concerns over bias and growing surveillance

  • Brazil police to use facial recognition to identify rioters
  • Cameras are unreliable, invasive and racist, say experts
  • Surveillance spreads fear in favelas

RIO DE JANEIRO - Police in Brazil plan on using facial recognition to identify protesters who rampaged through government buildings, escalating state surveillance in a move that has alarmed privacy and human rights experts.

Thousands of protesters vandalized Brazil's Supreme Court, Congress and presidential offices in Brasilia on Sunday, seeking to oust leftist President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva, who narrowly defeated incumbent Jair Bolsonaro in October's vote.

Police have arrested about 1,000 people, and said on Tuesday they would use biometrics "to identify those responsible for acts of vandalism".

Facial recognition operates in 21 of Brazil's 27 states, be it for monitoring urban transport or tracking school attendance.

A security camera sits on a building in New York City March 6, 2008. The New York City Police Department are using evidence from video tapes from nearby buildings to catch a suspect involved in a bombing at the Armed Forces Career Center. REUTERS/Joshua
Go DeeperAI surveillance takes U.S. prisons by storm
Security cameras near the Nagaworld casino and hotel complex in Phnom Penh, Cambodia.
Go DeeperActivists say China's new Silk Road equips autocrats with spy tech
A person gambles on a poker machine at a pub in Sydney, Australia, September 19, 2022. REUTERS/Loren Elliott
Go DeeperAustralia bets on facial recognition for problem gamblers

Rights groups say their rollout was opaque, with no public consultations or clarity on how the data is used and protected.

While authorities justify the surveillance on security grounds, technology experts worry about privacy violations and the potential for profiling and discrimination, particularly of Black and indigenous people.

Since 2019, 90% of people arrested using facial recognition in Brazil were Black, according to Panoptico, a project that monitors facial recognition use in Brazil.

"As a tool of mass surveillance, facial recognition is an expedited patchwork solution that demonstrably fails time and time again at meeting the security objectives it purports to enable," said Matt Mahmoudi, a researcher at Amnesty Tech, an arm of Amnesty International that counters digital repression.

"It also erodes fundamental rights. Historically, marginalized communities are at particular risk; as is the privacy of Brazilians at large," he added.

Favela under watch

For residents in Rio de Janeiro's Jacarezinho favela, facial recognition could soon be an everyday hazard.

Already, Jamila worries whenever her 23-year-old son steps out of their modest home, fearing he may be stopped by the police - or encounter something worse.

Her sprawling shantytown in Rio de Janeiro's north, home to about 60,000 mostly Black and poor residents, has endured decades of violence between criminal gangs and the police.

Last year, authorities said they would install nearly two dozen surveillance cameras in the favela, exacerbating Jamila's fears for her son.

"I worry that these cameras will be used against the young men in the favela - many are already frequently targeted by the police on false grounds," said Jamila, 57, who asked that her last name not be used because she feared retaliation.

"My son spent 30 days in juvenile detention in 2016 when he was mistaken for a criminal due to a false photo identification. I fear that it may happen again with these cameras," she told Context.

The Rio police did not respond to a request for comment.

A view of Jacarezinho favela in northern Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. Thomson Reuters Foundation/Leonardo Coelho

A view of Jacarezinho favela in northern Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. Thomson Reuters Foundation/Leonardo Coelho

A view of Jacarezinho favela in northern Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. Thomson Reuters Foundation/Leonardo Coelho

In-built bias?

Global use of facial recognition has grown rapidly, despite its poor track record identifying women and people with darker skin.

Aside from solving crimes, accessing apps or policing borders, it is also used to target dissidents and activists from as far afield as Iran to China.

Bolsonaro signed a pair of decrees in 2019 aiming to create a centralised database collating the personal and biometric information of Brazil's population of more than 200 million.

Thereafter, Rio de Janeiro's former governor Wilson Witzel rolled out facial recognition tools, saying they would help curb the city's rampant crime rate.

Dozens of cameras were deployed in Copacabana during Carnival, then expanded to other neighborhoods.

But the pilot project in Copacabana showed no reduction in crime, according to Panoptico.

The cameras also misidentified suspects in more than half of arrests, Panoptico said, citing police data.

After a 2021 shootout in Jacarezinho left at least 25 people dead, police stepped up their use of surveillance, tracking license plate numbers and faces throughout the favela.

Last year, hundreds of heavily armed police occupied the Jacarezinho neighborhood in a renewed security crackdown.

Facial recognition is part of the federal government's plan for increased security in the favela, but there is little transparency about how the data will be used, said Dani Monteiro, president of the Human Rights Commission at Rio de Janeiro's state assembly.

"We searched in official diaries, government websites and could find nothing on them," she said. "The programme came in overnight, and only in the fine print did they mention the cameras."

A spokesperson for Rio Governor Claudio Castro said they had appointed a committee to oversee the cameras' use, but did not say if they were addressing the concerns of civil rights groups.

Algorithmic discrimination

Worldwide, there is growing pushback against facial recognition, with several U.S. and European cities banning its use, and the United Nations high commissioner for human rights calling for a moratorium until safeguards are set.

Last year, a court in São Paulo ruled that the city's metro must stop using facial recognition, handing a victory to rights groups who had argued that it hurt vulnerable citizens, especially Blacks, due to its "algorithmic discrimination".

Rio is pushing ahead with new surveillance, installing smart streetlights fitted with WiFi and cameras. Of the 10,000 cameras, 40% have facial recognition, according to officials.

In Jacarezinho, four of the 22 cameras planned for the neighborhood will carry facial recognition capabilities.

Many residents are unaware their every move may be recorded, said Pablo Nunes, a coordinator of Panoptico.

The Rio police are among the deadliest in Brazil, according to official data, and Black people make up the majority of those killed by the police nationwide.

So the cameras are a volatile - and futile - addition to an already fraught environment, said Nunes.

"In their own studies they (police) state that they wish to use these cameras in order to help defend police officers in lawsuits," he said.

"There's no indication that they help reduce crime, or that they improve daily policing," he said.

(Reporting by Leonardo Coelho; Writing by Rina Chandran; Editing by Lyndsay Griffiths.)


Context is powered by the Thomson Reuters Foundation Newsroom.

Our Standards: Thomson Reuters Trust Principles


Tags

Facial recognition
Race and inequality
Tech and inequality
Data rights
Tech solutions

FEATURED PODCAST

An illustration photo shows the globe with a tree standing on top. On the left hand side, a red backed illustration shows barren trees and oil refinery towers. On the right hand side, a green backed illustration shows wind turbines and solar panels. A sound equaliser image crosses the screen to indicates audio.
6 EPISODES
Podcast

Just Transition

The human stories behind the shift to a green economy

An illustration photo shows the globe with a tree standing on top. On the left hand side, a red backed illustration shows barren trees and oil refinery towers. On the right hand side, a green backed illustration shows wind turbines and solar panels. A sound equaliser image crosses the screen to indicates audio.
Podcast




Get our data & surveillance newsletter. Free. Every week.

By providing your email, you agree to our Privacy Policy.


Today On Context