US cities seek to ‘Trump-proof’ inequality action ahead of vote

A climate protester interrupts the campaign event of Former U.S. President and Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump, in Indianola, Iowa, U.S., January 14, 2024. REUTERS/Brendan McDermid

A climate protester interrupts the campaign event of Former U.S. President and Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump, in Indianola, Iowa, U.S., January 14, 2024. REUTERS/Brendan McDermid

What’s the context?

Local officials race to safeguard momentum on environmental justice, inclusive economies, climate action and more

US Elections 2024: Read our full coverage.

Ahead of the Nov. 5 presidential election, U.S. cities are racing to safeguard momentum on what backers see as historic action on environmental justice and a range of new efforts to tackle racial, economic and geographic inequality.

After the COVID pandemic and protests following the death of George Floyd in 2020, racial and economic inequality moved to the centre of federal policymaking.

That includes, for instance, a mandate that 40% of benefits from federal climate, clean energy, housing and other investments go to communities considered under-invested or "overburdened by pollution", strategies that are now translating to new workforce development, cleaning up decades-old pollution and more.

Yet many worry the billions available in funding for such "environmental justice" and related considerations could be imperilled by a second Donald Trump administration.

U.S. President Joe Biden delivers remarks on the White House initiative on climate change, at the White House in Washington, November 14, 2023. REUTERS/Tom Brenner
Go DeeperBiden's push for US funding justice yet to level playing field
A woman and her son plant a sapling in the Southside area of Richmond, Virginia. Southside ReLeaf / Handout via Thomson Reuters Foundation
Go DeeperCan U.S. cities use climate plans to 'undo' racist legacies?
U.S. Vice President Kamala Harris and former U.S. President Donald Trump seen in a combination of file photographs. REUTERS/Marco Bello, Jeenah Moon
Go DeeperTrump-Harris debate: Where do they stand on the energy transition?

Cristina Calva, a public information officer for the city of Albuquerque in New Mexico said the new federal support had had "a huge impact” on the ability of cities to respond to concerns that inadequate investment in marginalised communities had left them uniquely vulnerable to pollution and climate change.

A first-ever city committee in Albuquerque is preparing to release a five-year environmental justice plan covering pollution remediation, clean energy, transit, affordable housing and more, she told Context.

"With all of this work we're doing to bring equity throughout the city, we're looking for ways to implement things that will not just disappear with a new administration," she said.

Trump campaign press secretary Karoline Leavitt said in an email that the former president's first term in office showed he was able to create a thriving economy. She pointed to a platform that includes pledges to end inflation, cut taxes for workers, rebuild urban areas and more.

"President Trump's 20 promises to the forgotten men and women represent a winning agenda to make our country strong, safe, healthy, wealthy, and great again," Leavitt said.

Vice President Kamala Harris is broadly expected to continue the current administration's approach to prioritising marginalised communities.

As a U.S. senator, Harris wrote several bills on the issue, including the Environmental Justice for All Act and the Climate Equity Act, while her presidential campaign focuses on creating an "opportunity economy" and highlights her work promoting an equitable post-pandemic recovery.

Even as the federal government is now helping local governments act on issues that have long proved intractable, the election uncertainty is prompting concerns that momentum could disappear before it has had a chance to have an impact.

"Communities are terrified that funding is going to go away," said Ella Mendonsa, a senior adviser to the NRDC Action Fund, which is affiliated with the Natural Resources Defense Council think tank.

Even with some money already out of the door, implementation of new programmes would be taking place well into the next administration, she said.

"Cities are really feeling threatened by the possibility of lawsuits and trying to make sure this money is already dispersed, because that threat of losing this funding or having it clawed back is very high," Mendonsa said.

Local residents take part in a protest in Chicago in November 2020. Ivan Moreno/NRDC/Handout via Thomson Reuters Foundation

Local residents take part in a protest in Chicago in November 2020. Ivan Moreno/NRDC/Handout via Thomson Reuters Foundation

Local residents take part in a protest in Chicago in November 2020. Ivan Moreno/NRDC/Handout via Thomson Reuters Foundation

'We've been here before'

Still, U.S. cities gained significant experience in filling a perceived gap in federal policy during the first Trump administration, Cleveland Mayor Justin M. Bibb said in an interview.

"We've been here before," said Bibb, who also chairs the national Climate Mayors group of nearly 350 mayors.

"America's mayors and Climate Mayors will work to continue to ensure that we take full advantage of the incentives, as we need to make sure we're addressing the climate crisis at the local level. We're already planning for either scenario," he said of the election outcome.

Those experiences also offer insight on steps cities can take today to seek to safeguard current policy priorities, said Deborah Archer, faculty director of the Community Equity Initiative at New York University School of Law.

Some of the most far-reaching aspects of the Biden administration's focus on inequality are concerned with undoing past damage to marginalised communities, Archer said, pointing to the example of an unprecedented $1-billion programme to reconnect Black communities divided by highways a half-century ago.

"Localities can Trump-proof some gains from the Biden administration by writing progressive federal policies into state laws and local ordinances," said Archer, who is also president of the American Civil Liberties Union.

For example, the Biden administration has created new federal rules aimed at removing barriers to housing – guidance that could now be vulnerable under a new administration. Yet California, Maine and others have codified these rules into state law.

An environmental protest sign hangs on a bridge in Chicago in 2023. Ivan Moreno/NRDC/Handout via Thomson Reuters Foundation

An environmental protest sign hangs on a bridge in Chicago in 2023. Ivan Moreno/NRDC/Handout via Thomson Reuters Foundation

An environmental protest sign hangs on a bridge in Chicago in 2023. Ivan Moreno/NRDC/Handout via Thomson Reuters Foundation

'Last line of defence'

The past four years have seen a sea change in putting inequality at the core of local economic development, expanding beyond the traditional metrics of job creation and growth in gross domestic product, said M. Yasmina McCarty, CEO and president of the New Growth Innovation Network, which works with cities across the country.

She pointed to new inclusive economic models in cities such as Tulsa, Oklahoma, and Topeka, Kansas, which have expanded their concept of economic growth to include poverty reduction and participation of traditionally marginalised groups.

Sector-specific work is adopting similar approaches, such as new jobs development in the marine economy along Rhode Island's coast or the aeronautics industry in Texas, which actively seek to involve marginalised applicants.

Such work has been made possible through an "unprecedented prioritisation of equity" from the federal government, well beyond a traditional focus on gender and race, McCarty said.

"To walk away from that would be regrettable and would leave a lot of cities and regions stuck in poverty."

For now, new local partnerships focused on this work are looking for funding alternatives, she said, expressing confidence the work would continue, if under other names.

As cities increasingly recognise the importance of inclusion for economic development, they have built on local efforts that grew under the Trump administration to provide "sanctuary" to migrants, said Rachel Peric, executive director of Welcoming America, a non-profit that works with cities.

"In the last Trump era, cities were the first line of action and the last line of defence," and today they are preparing to do the same, she said.

Cities increasingly recognise that openness to outsiders is important to address demographic and economic headwinds, Peric said, pointing to Dayton, Ohio. The former industrial city, Peric said, had "reversed 50 years of population decline and is now seeing economic gains, with people moving in, putting down roots, opening businesses".

Welcoming America lists hundreds of communities with similar policies, seeking to ensure they are open to newcomers including migrants, by boosting affordable housing and economic opportunities, tamping down on racism or school bullying, and more.

Ahead of the election, interest in such policies is again high, Peric said.

"We did see a big uptick in interest in 2016 in our membership, so we're expecting that again, as people want to be outspoken in their values." 

This story was updated on Tuesday October 22, 2024 at 10:27 GMT to correct the number of mayors in paragraph 18.

(Reporting by Carey L. Biron; Editing by Jon Hemming.)


Context is powered by the Thomson Reuters Foundation Newsroom.

Our Standards: Thomson Reuters Trust Principles


Former U.S. President Donald Trump takes the stage to address supporters at a rally in West Palm Beach, Florida, U.S., November 6, 2024. REUTERS/Brian Snyder

Part of:

US elections 2024: Trump's journey to the White House

With climate change, reproductive rights, socio-economic inclusion, and debates around tech AI figuring prominently, Context will keep you on top of the major developments

Updated: November 06, 2024


Tags

  • Race and inequality
  • Workers' rights
  • Economic inclusion




Get ‘Policy, honestly’ to learn how big decisions impact ordinary people.

By providing your email, you agree to our Privacy Policy.


Latest on Context