Afghans scramble to delete digital history, evade biometrics

An Afghan woman holds her phone in Kabul June 8, 2014. 
REUTERS/Ahmad Masood

An Afghan woman holds her phone in Kabul June 8, 2014. REUTERS/Ahmad Masood

What’s the context?

There are fears that government offices and aid agencies may fail to secure databases, leaving people vulnerable to attacks

  • Concerns that digital IDs and databases can be used to target people
  • Aid groups, government agencies responsible for securing systems
  • Rights groups advising activists on how to delete digital trails

By Rina Chandran

Thousands of Afghans struggling to ensure the physical safety of their families after the Taliban took control of the country have an additional worry: that biometric databases and their own digital history can be used to track and target them.

U.N. Secretary-General Antonio Guterres has warned of "chilling" curbs on human rights and violations against women and girls, and Amnesty International on Monday said thousands of Afghans - including academics, journalists and activists - were "at serious risk of Taliban reprisals".

After years of a push to digitise databases in the country, and introduce digital identity cards and biometrics for voting, activists warn these technologies can be used to target and attack vulnerable groups.

Go DeeperAfghanistan: Two years of Taliban rule
A woman holds up a device to take a picture of someone standing in front of a green wall
Go DeeperA year on, Afghans hide out fearing death by data
An Afghan refugee holds her passport in front of the German Embassy ​in a bid to acquire refugee visas from the European country, in Tehran, Iran September 1, 2021.
Go DeeperAs women flee Afghanistan, brain drain hits economy and girls' hopes

Tips to bypass facial recognition include looking down, wearing things to obscure facial features, or applying many layers of makeup, the guide said, although fingerprint and iris scans were difficult to bypass.

"With the data, it is much more difficult to hide, obfuscate your and your family's identities, and the data can also be used to flesh out your contacts and network," said Welton Chang, chief technology officer at Human Rights First.

It could also be used "to create a new class structure - job applicants would have their bio-data compared to the database, and jobs could be denied on the basis of having connections to the former government or security forces," he added.

The most "dire circumstance" would be to use the data to target anyone who was involved in the previous government, or worked in an international non-profit, or was a human rights defender, he told the Thomson Reuters Foundation.

Door to door

Even five years ago, the Taliban was using government biometric systems to target members of the security forces, checking their fingerprints against a database, according to local media reports.

On Monday, just hours after the militants rolled into the capital Kabul, there were fears that this was already happening.

"Taliban started door-to-door search" for government officials, former security forces members and those who worked for foreign non-profits, a Twitter user called Mustafa said on Monday, adding that journalists' homes were also searched.

A Kabul resident said in a private message that she had heard of house-to-house inspections, and that the Islamist militants were using a "biometrics machine".

The Taliban, in a statement, said it "assures all its citizens that it will, as always, protect their life, property and honour and create a peaceful and secure environment for its beloved nation."

But digital rights groups are already getting "significant numbers" of requests from civil society groups and activists on securing their digital presence, said Raman Jit Singh Chima, Asia Pacific policy director at Access Now.

"We are also very concerned about databases retained by aid agencies and other groups, and alarmed that there is no clarity whether mitigation measures are being taken to either delete or purge information that can be used to target people," he said.

The digital identity cards, the tazkira, can expose certain ethnic groups, while even telecom companies have a "wealth of data" that can be used to track and target people, he added.

The responsibility to secure data systems was ultimately that of the Afghan government, said Chang, although the U.S. forces and its allies probably had a role in "designing the systems in the first place and helping with implementation."

"Likely not enough deliberate planning was done at the outset of creating, maintaining and turning over the system in terms of risk assessments and prevention of misuse," he added.

Meanwhile, Afghans were doing what they could to scrub their digital profiles.

Boys and men were "frantically going through phones to delete messages they have sent, music they've listened to & pictures they've taken," BBC reporter Sana Safi wrote on Twitter on Sunday.


Context is powered by the Thomson Reuters Foundation Newsroom.

Our Standards: Thomson Reuters Trust Principles


An Afghan woman holds her phone after an election campaign by Afghan presidential candidate Ashraf Ghani Ahmadzai in Kabul June 8, 2014

Part of:

Afghanistan: Two years of Taliban rule

Two years ago, the Taliban took Kabul. From spiraling poverty to banning women from education, here are our stories on the impact

Updated: August 10, 2023


Tags

  • Digital IDs
  • Government aid
  • War and conflict
  • Tech and inequality
  • Data rights




Get our data & surveillance newsletter. Free. Every week.

By providing your email, you agree to our Privacy Policy.


Latest on Context